Wednesday, August 25, 2010

La Aroma de Cuba Robusto


This time I decided to try the La Aroma de Cuba Robusto, what's known as the new blend(the Pepin one). I've actually enjoyed the smaller sizes from the original blend, particularly the interlude and petite corona. I didn't care much for the big rang gauges, however. I've tried the edicion especial (EE) LAdC, but never tried these, so I decided to give them a shot.

Initial Impressions:This was a rather meaty robusto 5X(52?). I really don't like smokes above 50 RG sometimes, they're a little too big IMO. This cigar had a dark natural wrapper that was a little mottled and bumpy, not completely smooth. The cigar was firm to the touch; there were no soft spots. The cigar had a very faint aroma prior to lighting.

Smoking:This was a perfectly constructed cigar. The draw was good with a plentiful amount of smoke each and every puff. The cigar burned evenly and burned slow and cool, no overheating. The wrapper behaved well and did not crack or unravel. The ash was firm and white, staying on for over an inch before I ashed myself.

Taste:This was a medium bodied cigar, on the lighter side of medium. Absolutely smooth, no harshness whatsoever. This cigar started out with a lot of spice! And I mean...a lot of SPICE!. I could get a very spicy coffee-like taste for most of the smoke, with some hints of leather and a good bit of cocoa, but the spice was overpowering for a little while. Surprisingly the finish was very mild and stayed on the palate for only s short time. Smoking through the nose, the spice was excessive, but I could still get hints of cocoa and chocolate. About half way through the cigar, the spice died down significantly, but this was coupled with a somewhat bland flavor. For the rest of the smoke the taste was pretty boring.

Conclusion:This started out as a typical 'Pepin' product(at least what most people seem to label as typical) with plenty of spice that was really upfront. The spice, however, may have been a little too much. While the first half of the cigar was...interesting/eventful(?) the 2nd half of the smoke was somewhat disappointing. The construction was spot on.

Thursday, August 19, 2010

My Father Le Bijou 1922 Petite Robusto


Another cigar made by Don Pepin.


Well, I decided to light another new Pepin creation, the My Father La Bijou 1922 Petite Robusto. I've had the original My Father cigars, blended by Pepin's son Jaime Garcia, and really enjoyed the whole range, particularly the lancero. I haven't tried the La Bijou series yet, mostly because I thought it was just another silly line extension, but I decided to try one out.

Initial Impressions:This was a rather meaty rothschild/petite robusto reminiscent of some of the sizes made by General as well as the HdM Petite Robusto (a tasty little smoke). I believe this was the first rothschild made by DPG for any of his lines or his client lines. The wrapper was a dark natural color and very smooth, no bumps or prominent veins, and the cigar had a nicely done triple cap on top. The cigar was also firm to the touch, no soft spots. The cigar itself felt a little hefty, it seemed to be packed with tobacco. A pleasant and mild aroma came off of this cigar before lighting.

Smoking:The construction on this cigar was flawless. The draw was superb with a more than adequate amount of smoke with each puff. The wrapper stayed on well and did not crack or unravel. The cigar burned very cool and slowly as I puffed rather slowly again. The burn was excellent. The ash was firm and a beige-ish gray color, staying for half the smoke before I ashed it myself. Excellent construction.

Taste:This smoke can be best characterized as being medium -full bodied, closer to the full side. The flavor was pleasant and smooth the whole way through, no trace of harshness whatsoever. The cigar began with a blast of pepper and spice (and everything nice), but that immediately died down to a very subtle spice undertone. The dominant flavors for about the first half of the smoke were cedar and some leather. The taste of the tobacco was exceptional. The finish was very full bodied with a tasty sweetness and earthiness and stayed on the palate for a long time. As I smoked the cigar developed a very sweet coffee-like taste and some more complexity that I really cannot adequately describe. The finish continued to be very deep and pleasant. A pleasant aroma came off of this cigar while smoking.

Conclusion:Well...I'll just say it. This was one of the best cigar smoking experiences I have had in a while. A super tasty smoke with superb construction quality. This hit everything on my good smoke 'check-list'. This was one of those cigars I would recommend if someone asked me to name a good cigar. Compared to the El Triunfador from the previous review, this cigar knocked it out of the water. This cigar had amazing flavor in spades. Highly recommended, and I will definitely sample more of these.

El Triunfador No. 4


This is a cigar made for Pete Johnson by "Don Pepin" Garcia. Made from Nicaraguan tobacco in Pepin Garcia's factory in Miami.



El Triunfador No. 4

Initial Impressions: This was a svelte robusto with a beautiful dark natural wrapper that was very smooth, no bumps. The cigar was made with a triple cap. This cigar had a very pungent pre-light aroma that was very savory. This cigar was firm to the touch, no soft spots.

Smoking:This cigar had an excellent draw with a good volume of smoke. The wrapper did not crack or unravel from start to finish. The ash was firm and a marbled gray color. which stayed on for nearly half the smoke! The only issue that I encountered was that the cigar smoked a little hot at first, so I had to smoke it more slowly. Otherwise, this was a fine smoking experience.

Taste:I would describe this as a medium bodied cigar. The taste was smooth from start to finish, no trace of harshness or unpleasant flavors for the entire smoke. While smoking I got a very nice quality tobacco flavor that had some woodiness to it. There was a very pleasant mild spiciness to the flavor as well (unlike some of the other Pepin spice bombs). The finish throughout most of the smoke was mild and spicy, it only became fuller in the last third of the smoke. I could also get some hints of sweetness, but this woody-tobacco flavor predominated along with a mild and spicy undertone. The cigar gave off a very pleasant aroma while smoking.

Conclusion: A perfectly constructed cigar, as are almost all Tatuajes, which never seem to have any issues. The flavor was very pleasant, but straightforward. Not necessarily a bad thing, but at this price point I would expect some more complexity. While the taste may not have been complex, I found it enjoyable. Overall, a very good smoking experience!

Wednesday, August 11, 2010

Good Local Tobacco Shops

Here are some of the best local tobacco shops in the Baltimore and Pittsburgh areas.

Baltimore
1. The Humidour Cigar Shoppe: Over on York Rd. not too far from Hunt Valley. This is a very well run store with a lot of good brands and a knowledgeable staff. They have a lot of cool events during the year and its BYOB (at least it was the last time I went). The best part are the amenities. Free Wi-Fi, big flat screen TV, comfy chairs. A really chill place to come and smoke. Arguably the best in the Baltimore area.

http://www.humidour.com/

2. Fader's: On Reisterstown Rd. in the Valley Village Shopping Center(next to Cosi's). This is a smaller store, but it still has a nice selection. Lot's of pipe tobacco too. Not much room to sit around though. There are also locations in Towson and Catonsville.

http://www.faderstobac.com/index.php

3. Mt. Washington Cigar Co. : Located on Falls Rd. off of 83. Relatively big store, good selection, good place to lounge around and relax. I've only been there once, but liked it enough to recommend it to people.

http://www.mountwashingtoncigar.com/

4. Cross Street Tobacco: Downtown Baltimore over on Light Street. Easily the best tobacco store in the city itself. Very cozy, and a nice selection of pipe tobacco.

http://www.crossstreettobacco.com/#

Pittsburgh
1. Leaf and Bean
: Down on the Strip. Great Coffee, cool cigars, easily the most chill place you can go to in Pittsburgh, and they have live music sometimes. One of my favorite places to smoke a cigar and drink some tasty coffee. Highly recommended!

http://leafandbeanstrip.com/

2. Allegheny Smokeworks: Out in Blawnox off of 29. A really great tobacco shop! Great staff, great selection, and the people that work their know their cigars. Very nice lounge and great pipe tobacco selection. One of the best in the Pittsburgh area!

http://www.alleghenysmokeworks.com/

3. Bloom Cigar Company A.K.A. Bloom's: Down on the Southside on 12th st. right off of East Carson. This is a Pittsburgh landmark that's been around since 1955. A lot of 'interesting' people work and smoke there and the humidor has a bunch of nudie pictures posted all over the place. Worth a visit.

http://www.bloomcigar.com/

4. Continental Smoke Shop: This place gets a mention because it's the closest to Oakland. Located in Squirrel Hill on Murray Ave., past Jerry's records. A small shop with a decent selection, but it's close and accessible.





Sunday, August 8, 2010

A Word on Cigar Reviews & Ratings

Cigar smoking is a very subjective hobby where one guy's dog turd can be another man's favorite smoke. However, there are myriad ratings systems and countless reviews used and written by various websites and magazines (well one magazine, Cigar Aficionado) that give cigars a quantitative rating with a qualitative description of the smoking experience. Most of the time, however, there is no description for how cigars were rated or graded quantitatively and some of the values are just guesstimation or arbitrarily assigned. Reviewing a cigar's taste or flavor is also hit or miss, because it is extremely subjective.

There is no centralized rating system. What should you, the casual cigar smoker take from this? DON'T TRUST THE RATINGS, FIGURE OUT FOR YOURSELF. You can always go by the recommendations of others, but always try a cigar out for yourself, you are the best judge of what it is you enjoy. Reviews and ratings are helpful, but keep in mind that each person has a highly individualized palate and can taste and sense different things while smoking.

So how can you find out whether a cigar is good or not? There are two criteria, which are objective enough that everyone can understand what they mean and recognize them instantly:

1. A good cigar will have a good draw. This means that when you smoke it, it doesn't feel like trying to suck a golf ball through a straw and you are able to get a good volume of smoke out of the cigar.

2. A good cigar will have a 'smooth' flavor. A bad cigar tastes harsh. Basically, if a cigar is bad it will most likely taste like ass and smoking it will hurt you throat, and there will be a very harsh and unpleasant flavor. This usually means that the cigar has poor quality leaf (as in the case of gas station/pharmacy cigars) or the tobacco leaves have not been properly cured and aged. The cigars are harsh because the tobacco leaves still have a lot of ammonia (NH3).

If these two things aren't present, then your cigar most likely sucks. Construction is another key criteria, but that has a lot to do with how the cigars are stored rather than the cigars themselves.

So while you smoke take note of these things. I also recommend that you write your own reviews or make mental notes on how cigars taste and what flavors you can pick up. Eventually, once your palate develops, you'll get to a point where you can forget about all of the details and rate/review cigars on whether or not you will smoke them again simply if you find them enjoyable.

Sunday, August 1, 2010

Useful Cigar Information

While I try to provide some useful nuggets of information to people that read this blog, there are also some other websites and books that I have carefully perused, which I can highly recommend.

1. Wikipedia's Cigar Page: This Wiki page is actually fairly accurate and on the level. Tons of information about cigar structure, marketing, wrapper colors, pretty much anything cigar 101 related. A great source for some basic info.


2. The Complete Idiot's Guide to Cigars, 2nd ed. - Tad Gage: If you're looking for books, this is arguably the best one. The cigar brands he refers to are somewhat dated (to the mid-to-late 90's cigar boom), which is strange because the 2nd edition was published in 2006, but I guess the brands were not updated. There are particularly interesting chapters covering the history of cigars, how cigars are made, how cigar tobacco is grown, harvested, and cured, and a useful discussion on rating cigars. You can pick this book up and start reading from any chapter. Highly Recommended.


3. Cigarcyclopedia: This website is run by Richard Perlman, the author/publisher behind the yearly, Perlman's Encyclopedia of Cigars. One great part of this website is their retail comparison shopper, which is a compendium of prices from various retailers on popular brands. Also, as the name suggests, there is also a full encyclopedia of most hand-made cigar brands, which provides brand history, sizes, current production; it is very exhaustive. There is also some industry news, lots of reviews, plus a really cool "cigar school". A very comprehensive website!


Wednesday, July 28, 2010

Does Size Matter?

Size matters a lot when it comes to smoking cigars. People have their own preferences and proclivities, which make the hobby really individualistic and exciting.

I've noticed a somewhat interesting and troubling (at least for me) trend in cigar production that threatens this individualism that, in my opinion, is an integral part of the hobby. A lot of cigars being produced today come in only a few select sizes. Toros, robustos, chuchills, torpedos are usually the main variety and they are always big, hefty and thick. Cigars used to be produced in myriad sizes and shapes, but todays smokers favor the thick ring gauges. Ring gauges of 52-60, which used to be pretty rare, are common fare nowadays.

This trend is best evinced in the fact that Habanos SA (The Cuban cigar monopoly) is paring down their catalog by removing a lot of the smaller sizes leaving only thick ring gauges. Coronas, Corona Gordas, Lonsdales, Perfectos are all going the way of the dodo. A true shame, because some of the best havanas are of the smaller variety.

I personally prefer coronas, petite, coronas, and corona gordas as I believe that they provide the best balance in flavor. Thicker cigars can be harder to light and keep lit, but they do burn cooler because they have more surface area. In thinner cigars the wrapper, usually the highest quality tobacco leaf in the entire cigar, contributes more to the flavor.

A lot of cigar producers are making cigars that come in 50 ring gauge or greater. I guess there is just something to smoking a robusto or rothschild. This is epitomized by the NUB brand of cigars, short fat cigars that claim to capture the complex and enjoyable flavors of the latter parts of the cigar. Most experienced smokers will tell you that this is purely a marketing ploy. Common sense will tell you the same thing.

Thinner cigars need more care while smoking. You can't puff on them like a locomotive otherwise they will overheat and become unsmokable. To me there is a certain elegance in smoking thinner cigars, plus they take less time to smoke. Don't get me wrong, I enjoy robustos and churchills (A good churchill is tough to top, when they are on they are on and can make for a great smoking experience), but I like variety as well. Luckily, a lot of my favorite manufacturers still produce plenty of sizes to choose from.

The Ruminations of a Cigar Smoker Part 2

Why do I smoke cigars?

Explaining the hobby itself is weird enough. "Hi, my name is Ed. I like to take bunches of rolled up, old, dried up leaves, light them on fire, and smoke them." I always think, "Well...it's a vice, but I can be doing worse things." Just as some people have hobbies like cars, playing video games, my hobby is smoking cigars.

What I like about cigar smoking is that it is a very subjective experience, a 'to each his own' kind of thing. I like that it stimulates four senses, and all five sometimes. Tasting the tobacco, smelling the smoke, feeling the cigar, watching it slowly burn down to nothingness.

When you're smoking in company, listening to the conservations is always a great experience, no matter if they're serious, intelligent, mundane, or plain old raunchy. Smoking cigars with others builds a certain camaraderie that you have to experience for yourself.

Is it an addiction? I don't think so. The cigars are not really addictive in themselves, but the experience is addicting and sometimes one can feel a twinge in their heart when the cigar is finished. I've smoked cigars so tasty that it can be sad to watch them burn out and left as a smoldering butt. Wholly wonderful and enchanting smoking experiences can be few and far between, but when they happen it is great!

Smoking cigars allows me to kick back, relax, and think, even more so with three fingers of some nice scotch or whiskey (on the rocks, of course) or a nice cocktail. It is truly a pleasurable experience. It is one of life's simple pleasures.

Monday, July 26, 2010

More Cheap Smokes

Some more affordable cigars!

1. Little Havana Overruns III (LHO III): Some cheap high quality cigars made by my favorite cigar manufacturer, Pepin Garcia. These lovely smokes are overruns of his regular production lines. No pretty bands, but they still have first tier quality as good as the banded stuff. Highly Recommended!


2. Little Havana Overruns Lights (LHO Lights): A milder version of the above mentioned cigars.


Awesome (at least I think so) Cigar Quotes

"If I cannot smoke cigars in Heaven, I shall not go." - Mark Twain

"Eating and sleeping are the only activities that should be allowed to interrupt a man's enjoyment of his cigar." - Mark Twain

"Given the choice between a woman and a cigar, I will always choose the cigar." - Groucho Marx

"A good Cuban cigar closes the door to the vulgarities of the world." - Franz Liszt

"Do not ask me to describe the charms of reverie, or the contemplative ecstasy into which the smoke of our cigars plunges us." - Jules Sandea

"To smoke is human; to smoke cigars is divine." - unknown

My Favorite: “My rule of life prescribed as an absolutely sacred rite smoking cigars and also the drinking of alcohol before, after and if need be during all meals and in the intervals between them.” - Winston Churchill


"Happiness? A good cigar, a good meal, a good cigar and a good woman - or a bad woman; it depends on how much happiness you can handle." - George Burns

"Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar." (When asked his habit of smoking cigars was an oral fixation) - Sigmund Freud


Wednesday, July 21, 2010

Tatuaje Reserva SW


Initial Impressions: I got this at the B&M not too long ago and thougt that I would try it out. These are part of Tatuaje's Reserva line and this is the Churchill. The SW comes from the fact that these cigars are blended and rolled to mimic the Cuban H Upmann Sir Winston, arguably one of the best cigars available today. These are blended and rolled by Pepin Garcia (my favorite cigar maker) in Miami. This cigar had a very nice natural wrapper with a light oily sheen. It was smooth and had no blemishes. A mild aroma came off of this cigar pre-light.

Smoking: The draw began a little tight, but about an inch or so into the smoke it became perfect with lots of smoke. The burn was even from start to finish and the cigar burned cool, no overheating. The wrapper behaved well and did not unravel or crack. The ash was firm and white and stayed on until I ashed myself. Except for a tight draw for about 1 inch the cigar had perfect construction.

Taste: This was a medium bodied cigar that was 100% smooth with no harshness. The cigar started out with a heck of a lot of spice. It was pretty in your face (I liked it). Besides this spice there was also a very sweet tobacco taste that was very smooth. The finish was full and stayed on the palate for a long time and had a a very nice taste to it. The further I smoked the more subtle the spice became, but it remained for the entire smoke. At some point (about 2-3 inches in) I began to get a very nice "coffee"-like taste and the finish became very sweet. About 5 inches in the cigar tasted the best it had to that point and continued to get better, very pleasant and complex. A pleasing medium-bodied aroma came off of this cigar while smoking.

Conclusion: Another fantastic smoke here blended by the Pepin Garcia. Great construction and great taste on this as well. These are a bit on the expensive side, but I would be willing to get a few more to render a final verdict. All in all, a great smoke.

Tuesday, July 20, 2010

Good Cheap Smokes

Back again with some good cheap smokes that won't break the bank. They might not look pretty or have instant name recognition, but they sure are damn tasty. Try them out!

1. Devil's Weed
This cigar was the subject of my last review. I've had multiple sizes and they're all good. Let them rest for a week and they're even better.


2. La Aurora 2nd's
These cigars are 2nds, meaning they're either overruns from production, or have some superficial deficiencies in the wrappers. They are still just as good as the real thing (same tobacco, same rollers, same factory). I am partial to the corona size. Those of you from FTO liked these a lot. I do too. An excellent cigar. You can get 15 for $17.95.


3. Famous Nicaraguan Selection 3000
I've tried the robsuto and rothschild sizes and enjoyed them very much. I'm sure the other sizes are just as good. They come in bundles of 20. These cigars are on the more robust size and have some good spice to them.


The Ruminations of a Cigar Smoker Part 1

People buy expensive, nice looking, highly coveted cigars all the time. They usually save them for a special occasion/event. My thoughts...smoke them if you got 'em.

I remember my dad receiving a bottle of Johnny Walker Blue (the $200 a bottle stuff) as a gift. Instead of saving it for a special occasion he drank it in exactly the same manner as any other bottle of scotch or alcohol that he's ever bought or been given. He even shared it with my brother and I. My brother asked him, "Why not save it for a special occasion?" My dad replied, "I don't know whether or not I'll be hit by a bus while crossing the street tomorrow or slip on a bar of soap in the shower. That's why." (He's mentioned this before and since, leading me to believe he's probably had near death experiences with both a bus and a bar of soap.)

The message: enjoy each day like any other, because you never know what will happen tomorrow.

If you have good and expensive cigars don't let them just sit around looking pretty. Smoke them! Hell, even if you've got some cheapies around and are waiting to smoke them just nix that plan. Smoke them and enjoy them. Cigars are meant to be smoked, not sit around and look pretty. I think that this practice of saving valuable items for a special occasion is symptomatic of our bourgeois and proletariat backgrounds and upbringing of keeping valuable items because we don't know the next time we'll get our hands on them. I believe that we should instead treat these items as any other expendable items and use them. Have fun, treat yourself, because you don't know what tomorrow brings.

I also find that saving smokes for a special occasion builds up our expectations to a high degree, leaving us disappointed or upset when they don't reach this lofty bar. Instead, smoke them on a random day, any day, and you maybe pleasantly surprised. Collecting is truly a passion, but sometimes people focus too much on this aspect and not enough on the experience itself.

Smoke 'em if you got 'em!!!

Sunday, July 18, 2010

Devils Weed Nicot


Initial Impressions: This was a lovely looking corona gorda (5.5 x 46). It had a silky smooth natural wrapper with a nice oily sheen. No bumps. The cigar was firm to the touch, there were no soft spots. The cigar had a very pleasant pre-light aroma.

Smoking: This cigar had a great draw with a very good volume of smoke. It smoked very cool from start to finish, no over heating. The wrapper did not unravel or crack during the entire smoke. The ash was firm and light grey with some marbling and stayed on for over an inch before ashing. The construction was excellent.

Taste: This was a very pleasant medium-bodied cigar. It was smooth the whole way through and did not have any harshness or unpleasant flavors. Overall the cigar had a straightforward tobacco taste with lots of sweetness. The finish was pleasant and sweet and stayed on the palate for a long time. In the second half of the cigar I could also detect some complexity and could taste some very pleasant cocoa flavors. The finish also become more robust and even sweeter. The cigar had a very pleasant aroma while smoking.

Conclusion:Overall this was a very good cigar. Highly recommended, especially for the price. A box of 20 can be found on CI for $31.99, and it's well worth it. The construction was flawless and the taste was great. Not too complex, but it did not have to be because it was an excellent smoking experience.

Thursday, August 27, 2009

Ten Things to Know About Cigars

Been busy sorry for the lack of updates. Here are ten important things to know about cigar smoking that I wish i knew when I first started.

1. Invest in a good cutter, don't worry about spending $30 or more, it's worth it.
2. Thinner cigars are just as good if not better than big thick cigars.
3. More expensive does not mean better experience.
4. Smoke anything and everything, you never know what you might enjoy.
5. If you plan on buying a humidor, get Heartfelt Humidity Beads!!!
6. Never buy Cuban cigars on the beach, the street, or in some tacky store. They are supposed to be sold at high end locations.
7. Don't smoke too fast, you should take a puff once every minute or two.
8. Never save a cigar for later, either smoke it all in one sitting or toss it, otherwise it will taste like a dog turd.
9. Don't save special smokes for special occassions, you never know what lies in the future.
10. I've heard this one a million times and it's always true. Smoke what you like and like what you smoke, never let anyone tell you any different.

Thursday, August 20, 2009

Even More Cheap Smokes

Here are some more cheap (and good) smokes.

1. Magellan Dominicans - This is a very mild cigar, but it's pleasant, well built, and available for a great price. Get 50 for $35 or 100 for $55. The ring gauge varies from 38 to 42 becasue these are factory extras, but they are worth it. You might get a dud or two hear but for less than a dollar per, I don't mind tossing it for another. If you like mild cigars, this is a good cheap one for you.


2. Sancho Panza Double Maduro Quixote or La Mancha - These are Honduran cigars with a very dark maduro wrapper. The cheapest sizes are the Quixote (robusto) or the La Mancha (corona). You can find them online or in most tobacco shops. Online they are a little over $2 for a box of 20, in tobacco shops they're around $5.

3. Nestor Reserve Maduro - Another Honduran cigar here that has a nice maduro wrapper. It has a very 'earthy' sort of taste and you can pick up a lot of coffee and cocoa type flavors in this cigar. They're available at Cigars International for about $2 to $2.50 per cigar in bundles onf 25 depending on the size. Very tasty, for the smoker that enjoys full-bodied cigars.

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Flor de Oliva Torpedo

The Flor de Oliva is a budget line of cigars produced by the Oliva cigar manufacturer. These are servicable smokes that have an okay flavor. They are great for the price. Good for golf, yard work, or when you;ve been drinking a lot. These are a nice change of pace and good for a cheap cigar.

Initial Impressions:This was a torpedo sized cigar that had about a 50 rg? It also had a very pointy torpedo top, not like the dull ones you usually see. The wrapper was natural in color and fairly light. It was smooth and had no blemishes on it. The cigar was firm to the touch, no soft spots. A very strong pre-light aroma came off of this cigar before lighting.

Smoking:Excellent burn from start to finish, plus the burn remained cool and slow for the enitre smoke. Good draw but not a big nice volume of smoke that I enjoy. The ash was firm and white and stayed for up to an inch and a half before ashing myself. The wrapper behaved well and did not crack or unravel during the smoke.

Taste: This cigar was smooth except for the last third of the smoke, which had some bite and unpleasant harshness to it. On the whole this cigar was very medium in terms of body. For the first half of the smoke I got a real 'woody' tobacco flavor with some sweetness mixed in and a somewhat salty taste as well. The finish was fairly medium in terms of strengh and stayed on the palate for a long time and also had a sort of 'woody' salty taste to it. In the second half of the smoke the taste gained a very deep sweetness to it, but that soon became intermingled with some unpleasant harshness and some bite. The last third of the cigar had the same sweet flavor, which was mixed with some unpleasant flavor as well. A medium aroma came off of this cigar while smoking.

Conclusion: This cigar had great construction. The taste, while good at some points, left something to be desired at others. The last third of the cigar in particular wasn't very pleasant, but everything up to that point was okay. Based on the previous scale I would rate this cigar a 3, or average. Not bad, but not good for an okay smoking experience.

Issues with Blind Taste Testing

This post borrows a lot from this article as well as my own personal experiences: http://www.stogiefresh.com/journal/Cigar_Journal/Cigar_Science/Entries/2007/8/29_Great_Expectations%3A_What_Do_Blind_Cigar_Reviews_Really_Tell_Us.html - This is great article on Cigar blind taste testing.

A lot of the cigars on this blog are ones that I have written after doing a blind taste test(BTT) where the band of the cigar is removed and I have no knowledge of the cigar or what it is prior to smoking. However, how effective are these blind taste tests for cigar smokers?

Perception and expectations are very important in any taste test and blind taste testing for cigars tries to eliminate any perception or framing as a potential bias. The taste of the cigar is tied to your perceptions and expectations of the cigar, which are heavily influenced by price, rarity, manufacturer, country of origin, band/box design. A BTT tries to eliminate these perceptions/expectations by removing these factors because they are perceived as bias that detracts from the cigars inate qualities.

My personal problem with a lot of blind taste tests is sample size. The ones I do are pretty much just for fun, not research or serious study, and should be taken with a grain of salt. To get a good accurate taste profile for a particular cigar you would have to smoke many samples, a safe bet for me would be about 10 or 15, before you can come to a good conclusion (ideally the sample size would be even larger, but I'm being realistic). One cannot really deduce a cigars taste after one or two samplings, that's why almost all of the sticks that I do smoke blind and consider buying I continue sampling a couple more before committing to a box.

Another issue with blind taste testing is that in a 'real world application' of smoking cigars you almost never smoke cigars blind. When you go to a tobacco shop or buy cigars online you don't buy them with some sort of expectations or perceptions. Conducting a blind taste test of every cigar you try just isn't practicle.

A big problem I have seen in blind taste testing is that people don't do it blinded or blind folded! You might laugh, but visual cues can significantly help determine what a cigar is and create perceptions. For example, many Cuban cigars have a distinctive triple cap on the head of the cigar and in BTT's for guessing country of origin people often create perceptions based on these visual cues, which might still be incorrect because a lot of non-Cuban manufacturers also now make cigars with a triple cap.

Our very underdeveloped and untrained palates and sense of taste are also stumbling blocks to blind taste testing. In my personal experience out of the 50 or 60 cigars that I have smoked in blind taste tests, I have only gotten two completely correct. This was due to visual clues and rote memorization of the taste, not my tasting ability. I had smoked so many of these cigars I had memorized the taste. A lot of people claim to be able to taste differences between cigars, but I have seen a lot of 'experienced' and 'unexperienced' smokers fall flat on their faces in BTTs. It takes a lot of training and hard work to be able to taste at a professional level, and even then it's still hit or miss sometimes. Also, our sense of taste and what we enjoy is different for every individual. Taste is extremely subjective and I have seen countless reviews of the same cigar that aren't even minutely close to one another.

In short, blind taste testing can be fun, but if you are only tasting one or two cigars it might not be that helpful. What's good for me may not be good for you and vice versa. Blind cigar tasting is really applicable because we almost never encounter it when actually smoking cigars. I hope that I have helped with the problems surrounding blind taste testing.

Here are some links for further reading:
http://www.puff.com/forums/vb/general-cigar-discussion/130048-great-moki-challenge-begins.html
This is a rather lengthy thread at a cigar forum where I used to participate, but has a lot of insight on the subjectivity and innaccuracy of tasting in any form.

http://www.stogiefresh.com/journal/Cigar_Journal/Cigar_Science/Entries/2007/8/29_Great_Expectations%3A_What_Do_Blind_Cigar_Reviews_Really_Tell_Us.html
The same article at the beginning of the post, great reading!

Wednesday, August 5, 2009

Tobacco Tax Broken Down by State

Here is a link of the various tobacco taxes (cigar, cigarette, snuff, chew, and pipe tobacco) by state:

http://www.tobaccofreekids.org/research/factsheets/pdf/0169.pdf

*It is interesting to note that Pennsylvannia and Florida are the only two states in the country that don't levy any sort of cigar tax. Also, PA has no state tobacco tax besides cigarette taxes.

Go Pennsylvannia!!!

Padilla Habano Robusto

This is a cigar from the Padilla family manufacturers. They release a bunch of different blends of cigars, mostly available at http://www.cigarsinternational.com/ or other online cigar vendors, but you can find them at some tobacco shops. This was a good medium-bodied cigar you can get for a decent price.


Initial Impressions: The wrapper was very nice and fairly smooth with some bumps, no blemishes, and had a nice oily sheen to it. Gave off a very nice pre-light aroma of tobacco.

Smoking: As you can see from the pictures this stick was flawlessly constructed. The burn was even the whole way through, the wrapper was flawless, it never burned too hot, and the ash was firm and stayed on as long as possible, before I had to take the band off. The draw was superb on this cigar as well from start to finish. Perfectly constructed smoke this time around no complaints at all. Hands-down perfect.

Taste: This cigar was a medium-bodied gem that was smooth the whole way through. The taste started out very "woody" and the finish had a sweet tobacco taste that stayed on the palate for a short time. At around the sixth and seventh pictures the taste began to change to a sweet "cream" like taste and the finish retained that sweet tobacco flavor but became more full and stayed on the palate longer. The flavor was so good here that even a slug decided to come and see what was up. After the ash finally fell off and for the rest of the smoke the "cream"-like flavor continued, but the stick increased a little in complexity and I could detect some "coffee"-like and "nut"-like flavors here and there. The finish remained full and sweet and stayed on the palate for a long time for the rest of the smoke. This cigar retained good taste characteristics even down to the nub where it just became too hot to smoke, never turned harsh. The aroma from this cigar was nice and lite.

Conclusion: For a stick I never tried before I thought my trigger finger might have been to itchy and I was in for a dissapointment. This cigar, however, went far and above my expectations. I read that these received a 90 rating in either CA or CI and that rating was well deserved. One of the best constructed cigars that I have ever smoked. The medium-bodied taste here was also a nice change of pace from the more full-bodied smokes I've been enjoying recently. The tastse was also very pleasant and had some nice complexity to it that really surprised me. You can find these sticks at B&M's ranging from about $5-$6, online boxes of 20 I've seen can go anywhere from $85-$120. Even at this price that value if very good. At less than $3 a stick via joecigar the value is really amazing. Here's to hoping that the rest of the cigars are just as good.